Kuwait: Lift Protest Ban
|Publisher||Human Rights Watch|
|Publication Date||10 November 2012|
|Cite as||Human Rights Watch, Kuwait: Lift Protest Ban, 10 November 2012, available at: http://www.refworld.org/docid/50a2163b2.html [accessed 15 December 2017]|
Kuwait's authorities should revoke a ministerial order to ban all demonstrations because it denies the right to peaceful assembly. Since October 15, 2012, security forces have used teargas and stun grenades to disperse at least three large rallies protesting an effort by the country's ruler to amend the country's electoral law in a way that might reduce opposition representation in parliament.
Opposition groups – consisting of Islamists, liberals, and nationalists – have called for another gathering in al-Erada Square in front of the National Assembly building in Kuwait City on November 11, marking the 50th anniversary of the country's constitution.
"The right to peaceful assembly is enshrined in the constitution Kuwaitis will be celebrating," said Joe Stork, deputy Middle East director at Human Rights Watch. "Authorities should lift the ban and permit people to express their views."
Some of the rallies brought out tens of thousands of protesters, such as a "March of Dignity" on October 20 – the largest in the country's history. The Interior Ministry justified the use of force to disperse protesters, saying that they "rioted and used violence," "threw stones at police forces," and "blocked traffic." At the October 20 event, dozens of people were injured, according to news reports, including at least 11 policemen, according to the Interior Ministry.
However accounts from Kuwaiti human rights activists and videos examined by Human Rights Watch indicate that the demonstrations have been largely peaceful. In any event the use of violence by some protesters would not justify as drastic a step as the prohibition of all demonstrations. Restrictions on the right to peaceful assembly must be proportionate, Human Rights Watch said.
Sheikh Sabah al-Ahmad al-Sabah, Kuwait's emir, issued the decree to amend the electoral law on October 19. The next day, the Interior Ministry warned that it would "absolutely not allow" sit-ins, gatherings, and marches regardless of how long they will last except within a designated area near the National Assembly building in Kuwait City.
After the October 20 protest, the ministry issued another statement on October 21 saying that it would "absolutely not allow any marches regardless of the reasons and motives."
The political upheaval in Kuwait began on June 18, when the ruler suspended the parliament that had been elected in February for a month following growing tensions between the legislature and the government. On June 20, the constitutional court voided the February elections and reinstated the previous parliament, elected in 2009, which included more government supporters.
In August the government petitioned the court to allow it to amend the electoral law to reduce the number of people for whom each eligible voter can cast a vote from four to one in parliamentary elections. Opposition groups strongly oppose such a change which they have described as an attempt to reduce the opposition presence in future parliaments. The groups say that the next elected parliament should make any needed changes to the law.
On September 25 the constitutional court rejected the government's request. On October 7 the emir dissolved the reinstated 2009 parliament and set December 1 to elect a new parliament. Then on October 19, he changed the electoral law by decree.
On October 29 authorities arrested Musallam al-Barak, a former member of parliament, on charges of insulting the ruler after he gave a speech at the "March of Dignity" demonstration saying, "Your Highness… we will not allow you govern autocratically." According to Kuwait's constitution the emir is "immune and inviolable."
On October 31 police clashed with about 200 of al-Barak's supporters marching toward the Central Prison calling for his release. He was released hours later on 10,000 dinars (US$35,500) bail. His first court session is scheduled for November 13. According to news reports three other former parliament members have also been charged with "insulting" the emir.
On November 4 security forces used teargas and stun grenades to disperse thousands of people gathered in the Mishrif area, south of Kuwait City, after security forces blocked main roads leading to Kuwait City. Mohamed al-Humaidi, director of the Kuwait Society for Human Rights, told Human Rights Watch that a police lieutenant pushed him and threatened to beat him, "He said he knew me and my organization and that he was not happy we were monitoring rights violations." Al-Humaidi said he has filed a complaint against the lieutenant.
On November 5 the emir, in a televised speech, said that he will go ahead with his electoral law decree and vowed not to tolerate "destabilization of the country."
Kuwait ratified the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) in 1996. Article 21 of the ICCPR states that "the right of peaceful assembly shall be recognized," and that "no restrictions may be placed on the exercise of this right other than those imposed in conformity with the law and which are necessary in a democratic society in the interests of national security or public safety, public order, the protection of public health or morals or the protection of the rights and freedoms of others."
"The government has an obligation to respect the right to gather peacefully regardless of whether demonstrators support or oppose its policies," Stork said. "If force is required to quell violence by protesters it should be the absolute minimum necessary to protect lives and property."