Burundi government harassing independent broadcasters
|Publisher||Committee to Protect Journalists|
|Publication Date||3 August 2011|
|Cite as||Committee to Protect Journalists, Burundi government harassing independent broadcasters, 3 August 2011, available at: http://www.refworld.org/docid/4e452a802.html [accessed 16 August 2017]|
|Disclaimer||This is not a UNHCR publication. UNHCR is not responsible for, nor does it necessarily endorse, its content. Any views expressed are solely those of the author or publisher and do not necessarily reflect those of UNHCR, the United Nations or its Member States.|
New York, August 3, 2011 – The government of Burundi President Pierre Nkurunziza is attempting to silence critical press coverage of his administration with incessant judicial harassment of two of the country's leading independent broadcasters, the Committee to Protect Journalists said today.
Burundi journalists march on World Press Freedom Day. (Jean Pierre Aimé HARERIMANA)
Since sweeping the presidential and parliamentary elections unopposed in May 2010, Nkurunziza's second term has been criticized by international human rights organizations over human rights abuses, including the 10-month imprisonment of journalist Jean-Claude Kavumbagu, and violent unrest threatening a fragile peace agreement signed after a 13-year civil war, according to news reports. In response to critical coverage by Radio Publique Africaine (RPA) and Radio Isanganiro, Nkurunziza administration prosecutors and the government-controlled national media regulator, the National Communications Council (CNC), have in recent weeks used court summons, imprisonment, and threats of closure to silence the broadcasters, according to CPJ research.
"The constant legal harassment by Burundian authorities is a clear attempt to extinguish any criticism aired by private broadcasters," said CPJ East Africa Consultant Tom Rhodes. "Authorities, including the National Communications Council, must allow these stations to work in peace without using a politicized judiciary to silence them."
On Monday, state prosecutors in the capital, Bujumbura, summoned News Editor Patrick Mitabaro of Radio Isanganiro for the second time since July, Isanganiro reporter Désiré Hatungimana told CPJ. Prosecutors accused Mitabaro of insulting the judiciary by airing comments by the imprisoned Burundi Bar Association President Isidore Rufyikiri suggesting the executive controlled the courts, according to local journalists. In a May 2011 report, the United Nations Independent Expert on the human rights situation in Burundi, Fatsah Ouguergouz, expressed serious concerns about "the lack of independence of the judiciary" in Burundi.
Mitabaro was summoned for another interrogation on a separate, unknown matter on Tuesday, Hatungimana said. Back in May, state prosecutors had summoned Mitabaro and accused him of broadcasting information that jeopardized state security over an interview in which the former spokesman of an opposition party criticized a government proposal to reform political parties, according to news reports.
State prosecutors also questioned RPA Editor Bob Rugurika, for the fourth time since July 18, over a broadcast raising questions about the integrity of Léonce Ndarubagiye, the official responsible for setting up Burundi's Truth and Reconciliation Commission, according to local journalists. RPA had cited a 1996 U.N. report that linked Ndarubagiye to a massacre of ethnic Tutsis. Immediately after the broadcast, on July 23, CNC President Pierre Bambasi released a public statement declaring the news broadcast to be an "incitement to ethnic hatred, and therefore capable of having negative effects on reconciliation and the security of the population," according to news reports.
Following this interrogation, a magistrate summoned Rugurika for another interrogation, on August 9, on an unknown, separate matter, the journalist told CPJ. During a previous July 18 interrogation, state prosecutors had accused him of broadcasting information "likely to incite civil disobedience" in connection with programs featuring opposition parties Front for Democracy in Burundi and Alliance of Democrats for Change, according to local journalists.
Journalists from RPA's station in the northern town of Ngozi have also been summoned. On Friday and Monday, a state prosecutor questioned bureau chief Léonce Niyongabo and reporter Yvette Murekesabe about a story implicating a member of state security in a rape, according to local journalists.
In a move seen as an attempt to frustrate RPA's legal defense, authorities jailed the radio station's lawyer, François Nyamoya, on July 29, on spurious charges of witness tampering in a case in which he had successfully defended a suspect in the 2001 murder of World Health Organization Burundi Representative Kassy Manlan, according to local journalists. The case has been closed since 2003, and Burundi's code of criminal procedure forbids prosecution on an offense if the case has been closed for more than three years, according to the same sources.
Burundi authorities have consistently harassed both RPA and Radio Isanganiro this year over their coverage. Authorities imposed a four-day suspension on a popular RPA talk show in April, and four RPA reporters – Zirampaye Raymond, Domithile Kiramvu, Bonfils Niyongere, and Philbert Musobozi – are battling criminal defamation charges filed by Evrard Giswaswa, the mayor of Bujumbura, over October 2010 reports of an alleged nightclub brawl involving him, according to local reports.
EDITOR'S NOTE: The date Nyamoya was jailed has been corrected in the ninth paragraph.