Prosecuting Mali's Extremists
|Publisher||Institute for War and Peace Reporting|
|Publication Date||8 February 2013|
|Citation / Document Symbol||ACR Issue 338|
|Cite as||Institute for War and Peace Reporting, Prosecuting Mali's Extremists, 8 February 2013, ACR Issue 338, available at: http://www.refworld.org/docid/511b5f4b2.html [accessed 25 April 2014]|
|Disclaimer||This is not a UNHCR publication. UNHCR is not responsible for, nor does it necessarily endorse, its content. Any views expressed are solely those of the author or publisher and do not necessarily reflect those of UNHCR, the United Nations or its Member States.|
While the conflict has been seen as Islamists vs Malian government, that is a great oversimplification. People in the northern desert region have felt neglected for decades. The most vocal separatists are the Tuareg, a nomadic group spread across the Sahara in Niger, Mali and Algeria. The Islamists have sought to capitalise on these grievances, although they have little in common other than a shared hostility to national governments.Islamists
Ansar al-Dine is a home-grown Islamic group that recruits mainly from the Tuareg. Led by Iyad ag-Ghali, from Mali, the group has been linked to al-Qaeda. Unlike the nationalist groups below, it rejects calls for a separate Tuareg state, and instead wants Islamic law to be imposed over the whole of Mali. Despite these differing aims, Ansar al-Dine tends to avoid conflict with the Tuareg separatists, because of their shared ethnic identity.
Al-Qaeda in the Islamic Maghreb (AQIM) is led by Algerian-born militant Abu Musab Abdel Wadoud. Many of its core members reportedly come from Algeria and Mauritania, but it has been attracting new recruits from the Tuaregs of northern Mali. Its exact aims remain unclear, beyond a desire to imposed a strict interpretation of Islam across the region.
The Movement for Unity and Jihad in West Africa is a splinter group of AQIM, founded in mid-2011. Although it shares many of its aims, the leaders of this new group are believed to have broken away because of Algerian dominance within AQIM. Its leadership structure is unclear.
Mokhtar Belmokhtar's group, sometimes known as Al-Mulathameen ("the masked men"), is most famous for taking hundreds of hostages at a gas plant in Algeria in January 2013. Belmokhtar is a hardened jihadist, and most of his men are Algerian. It has been reported as operating in northern Mali.Tuareg Nationalists
National Movement for the Liberation of Azawad, MNLA, first emerged on the scene at the end of 2011. It is believed to have been established by senior commanders in the Libyan army, who fled the country following the ousting of Muammar Gadaffi. The group's leader, Bilal Ag Cherif, served in the Libyan army under colonel Gadaffi, but was originally born in northern Mali. The MNLA's ranks were swollen when two pre-existing separatist movements – Northern-Mali Tuareg Movement and Azawad National Movement – joined.
National Front for the Liberation of Azawad, FNLA, is a smaller group with broadly similar aims to the MNLA. It was established in April last year, primarily to counter the religious fundamentalism that was starting to spread across the north of the country, but also with a strong separatist agenda. The FNLA is strongly opposed to the imposition of Sharia law.Pro-government
A number of ethnic militia groups have established themselves in northern Mali to counter historical Tuareg dominance. Ganda Koy claims to represent the Songhai ethnic group, whilst Ganda Izo champions the cause of the Fulani. Some have suggested that the Malian government has used them to fight a proxy war against the Tuareg rebellion.
TAKING ON OPAQUE ISLAMIST GROUPS
Although the prosecutor will look at abuses committed by all sides in the conflict since July 2012, Mali is the first time the ICC will have to tackle armed Islamist groups. Such are the complexities of applying international law to groups of this kind that some experts believe prosecutions could embolden rather than deter the militants.
The French military intervention has already allowed extremists to portray the West as anti-Islamic, and prompted a terrorist alert in Paris.
Action by the ICC – already perceived as a western institution in some parts of the world – could be a gift to Islamic extremist propagandists.
Liaquat Ali Khan, a law professor at Washburn University in Kansas with particular expertise in Islam, has some reservations about how effective the ICC can be in Mali.
"The ICC is making an almost symbolic gesture – that it dislikes or wants to discourage extremist violence, but its actual impact on these groups is going to be minimal," he said.
Investigating Islamic fighters so committed to their cause raises big questions about one of central premises of international justice – using the threat of prosecution to prevent atrocities.
"I would be surprised if the ICC for some reason has an impact on extremist groups in Mali, whilst it has consistently failed to have an impact on atrocity crimes in other regions where religious motivations were not even present," said Madeline Morris, an expert on counterterrorism law and policy at Duke University School of Law in Durham, United States. "Why would a person who is willing to risk life and limb in committing widespread atrocities suddenly find himself deterred by the prospect of a prosecution in The Hague?"
Usama Hasan, who in 1990-91 fought in the mujahedin war against the Soviet-backed government in Afghanistan, is familiar with the mindset of such groups. He now works for the Quilliam Foundation, a London-based think-tank that campaigns against extremism.
"The hard core military groups won't engage and they won't lay down arms, so sadly the only way you can deal with them is militarily," he said. "Indicting leaders of extremist groups would simply reinforce the belief that the western world is against them. Islamic leaders don't care about prosecution – they see this as a way towards martyrdom."
Assuming the ICC prosecutor can bring evidence of abuses committed by insurgents, finding someone to charge will present its own problems.
Khan says that given the diffuse and complex structure of Islamist groups, the challenge is going to be to link atrocities to senior leaders.
"One of the groundbreaking [elements] of the ICC was that leadership should not be immune. You can now get to the prime ministers, the presidents, the generals and even the lawmakers," he said. "But it's difficult to prosecute a leader who has not directly committed any of the [crimes]."
The concept of "command responsibility", enshrined in the Rome Statute, the ICC's founding treaty, holds that leaders are culpable if they fail to act to prevent their subordinates from committing crimes. But that implies a clear hierarchical structure that might not be present – or at least provable – in northern Mali.
"It may be that you need to have a looser category to punish the leader who does not enter into the nitty-gritty planning of more definable crimes," Khan said.
ALL PARTIES TO THE CONFLICT
When the ICC first began looking at the situation in Mali last year, the environment seen from outside was one of general chaos – a military coup in March created a vacuum of power, especially in the ungoverned north where Tuareg rebels took the opportunity to gain ground, and were joined by hard-line Islamists. (See ICC Turns Attention to Mali.)
This situation changed since then, especially with France's intervention on the government side, yet the ICC still needs to be seen to be even-handed.
"The ICC has been looking at Mali for some time, but the problem is that as soon as the case was opened, it coincided with a broader political movement on the part of countries such as France, the US and the UK," Leslie Vinjamuri, a senior lecturer in international relations at the School of Oriental and African Studies in London, explainded. "Now the big question is going to be whether the ICC will look at both sides."
Prosecutor Bensouda appears acutely aware of the need for a balanced approach. A week after the ICC formally announced the launch of an investigation into Mali, she released a statement indicating that she was aware of reports that armed forces working for the Malian government might also have committed abuses.
Vinjamuri says this approach will be severely tested if the available evidence indicates that anti-government forces are the worst offenders.
"I think it's very smart on her [Bensouda's] part to stress the mandate that she has to look at everything in the country, without coming out and pronouncing on any particular part of the case, but the big question now is over the follow-through," she said. "We'll have to wait and see what happens. If the evidence comes through and comes down on only one side, then this could reinforce the idea that the ICC is serving the political interests of the West."
The court's mandate is to look at the situation as a whole, rather than focus on one side or the other. But in Mali the dynamics of an investigation are likely to be quite different.
Peter Chilson is a professor of English at Washington State University who knows Mali well. He has visited the country on numerous occasions over the past three decades, and recently visited refugee camps to talk to people about what they had witnessed.
"In the north of the country, the jihadists have never really tried to hide the atrocities that they have committed, and have certainly never denied them. In fact, they have done everything short of videotaping their atrocities to publicise what they are doing," he said. "By contrast, the military junta is very keen for unverified reports of reprisal attacks not to be linked to them."
That could make it easier to uncover evidence of abuses by Islamic and Tuareg groups than by the Malian army and its paramilitary allies.
Moreover, the ICC is in Mali at the request of the government. If it starts looking too closely at the actions of the military, it could find that cooperation quickly dries up.
At the same time, Chilson believes that the threat of prosecution would serve to deter abuses by government forces, unlike their opponents.
"I think the publicity of an actual prosecution against a Malian army officer would be more valuable in terms of shaming the Malian army, in terms of stopping these atrocities, whereas such a prosecution could not shame the jihadists into stopping because of their religious convictions," Chilson said.
Florent Geel, head of the Africa desk at the International Federation for Human Rights, FIDH, thinks there already signs that Malian commanders are taking note of the ICC, but on the ground, the average ordinary soldier may not have heard of the court.
"We believe that many of the soldiers allegedly committing crimes are doing so out of vengeance for harm suffered, rather than following orders, so I'm not sure that the ICC investigation will change a lot," Geel said. "However, I think it is slowly changing the upper hierarchy, with military commanders instructing soldiers to be more respectful and to stop killing civilians."
In other countries where the ICC has operated, it has been difficult to prove that the deterrent factor actually works.
For many, it is important that the ICC is seen to take a stand against the Islamic jihads committing atrocities in northern Mali, but there remains a strong question mark over how effective it can be in the fight against terrorism.
DISENTANGLING THE ISSUES
The situation in Mali is exceptionally complicated, with a number of incoming Islamist groups aligning themselves with others like the Tuareg who have longstanding grievances. And these disparate groups have shown a tendency to converge, with Tuareg being drawn into the "outside" groups.
On the government side, too, there are paramilitary groups whose activities the ICC will have to look at.
Hasan, from the Quilliam Foundation, says the only way of winning this war is by addressing the root causes of insurgency.
Hard-core militants may not be defeated, but they can be greatly weakened by stripping away their support on the ground.
"The key to weakening al-Qaeda is to address the underlying and national grievances of the Tuareg and other local groups," said Hasan. "There has to be a political solution to this, in order to reduce the support base for the Islamists."