Occupied Palestinian Territory: Growing Palestinian displacement in West Bank Area C
|Publisher||Integrated Regional Information Networks (IRIN)|
|Publication Date||17 August 2011|
|Cite as||Integrated Regional Information Networks (IRIN), Occupied Palestinian Territory: Growing Palestinian displacement in West Bank Area C, 17 August 2011, available at: http://www.refworld.org/docid/4e4e043e2.html [accessed 18 September 2014]|
Each year, hundreds of Palestinians in Area C have their homes demolished by the Israeli authorities because they are unable to obtain permits for their buildings, according to the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA). Area C covers 60 percent of the West Bank with a Palestinian population of about 150,000.
Israel retains military authority and full control over building and planning in Area C: as much as 70 percent of it is inaccessible to Palestinians, classified as Israeli settlement areas, firing zones, or nature reserves.
In the remaining 30 percent there are a number of other restrictions that reduce the possibility for Palestinians to obtain a building permit, reports OCHA. In practice, Palestinian construction is normally permitted only within the boundaries of a plan approved by the Israeli Civil Administration, which covers less than 1 percent of Area C, much of which is already built-up, according to OCHA.
Many Palestinians living in Area C are left with no choice other than to build without a permit.
Israel says authorities have only demolished illegal structures, and that Jewish and Palestinian residents in Area C are subject to the same restrictions.
An August 2011 OCHA report highlights the concerns of 13 Area C communities, including restrictive and discriminatory planning and zoning policies which limit Palestinian construction and use of the land, and lack of effective law enforcement in response to settler attacks.
Also, movement and access restrictions, like those created by Israel's "Separation Barrier", limit access to land and water resources for many communities.
Residents of Khallet Zakariya, located in Area C south of Bethlehem say Israeli authorities are demolishing their homes and settlers have destroyed their livelihoods in an effort to force the community to relocate.
Farmer Mohamed Khalil, 55, from Khallet Zakariya, says Israeli settlers ruined about half a hectare of his agricultural fields in June and spray-painted "death to Arabs" in black on the wall of his home, which is still visible.
"It's not the first time settlers destroyed my land," said Mohamed. "It takes 3-4 years to cultivate crops of grapes and plums."
The lost crops will affect income for three families, including 19 people. Mohamed has filed a complaint with Israeli police.
According to Mohamed, officials from the Civil Administration, the Israeli governing body that operates in the West Bank, came and offered to relocate his community of about 350 people to an area west of Bethlehem called Nahhlin.
"My father cultivated this land - we declined," he said.
Ido Hevroni, a resident of neighbouring Israeli settlement Alon Shvut with a population of about 3,000, located south of Khallet Zakariya, says there is peace between his community and Palestinian families.
"I am against any illegal structure, Palestinian or Israeli," said Hevroni, as he and his eight-year-old daughter walked through Khallet Zakariya.
With settlement Bat Ayin located directly west and settlement Rosh Zurim directly to the north, residents of Khallet Zakariya say there is a strategy to force them out to allow settlement expansion.
However, expansion has mostly been in larger settlements over the past year, according to Israeli NGO B'Tselem.
Fatima Saed, her husband Mahmoud, and their four children had 20 minutes notice to pack their belongings and evacuate their home in Khallet Zakariya before it was bulldozed by Israeli authorities on 25 July.
"Our lawyer was not informed that we had lost our court case disputing the demolition order for our home," said Fatima. Her family is now living at her brother's house nearby, with 21 people crammed into two rooms.
"We built here without a permit, because my family owns the land," she said.
In the first six months of 2011, OCHA reports that the Israeli authorities demolished 342 Palestinian-owned structures in Area C, including 125 residential "structures", displacing a total of 656 Palestinians, including 351 children - almost five times as many demolitions and people displaced as during the first half of 2010, according to OCHA.
Maj Guy Inbar, Israeli coordinator of government activities in the occupied Palestinian territory (COGAT), told IRIN: "There is no policy to move people from their homes."
He acknowledges, however, that Israel has increased action to monitor illegal building, both in Jewish and Palestinian sectors within Area C.
"A similar number of illegal Israeli and Palestinian structures have been demolished by Israel so far in 2011," said Inbar, and "Israel is working to approve and authorize more areas within Area C that Palestinians will be permitted to live [in] and build [on]."
Few building permits
B'Tselem spokesperson Sarit Michaeli said: "Israeli settlements were built in contravention of international law in the West Bank, while the Palestinian population in Area C is under occupation and protected by international law."
Israeli NGO Bimkom, comprised of planners and architects to strengthen human rights in the field of planning, published a comprehensive report in 2008 detailing what it describes as separate planning systems for Israeli settlements that allow for growth and expansion.
From 2000 to 2007, the Civil Administration approved 5 percent of the applications for building permits submitted by Palestinians in Area C. The total number of building permits issued to Palestinians during these seven years was 91, an average of 13 building permits per annum, reports Bimkom.