UN vote on Goldstone report a defining step for accountability
|Publication Date||6 November 2009|
|Cite as||Amnesty International, UN vote on Goldstone report a defining step for accountability, 6 November 2009, available at: http://www.refworld.org/docid/4af9267226.html [accessed 2 September 2015]|
|Disclaimer||This is not a UNHCR publication. UNHCR is not responsible for, nor does it necessarily endorse, its content. Any views expressed are solely those of the author or publisher and do not necessarily reflect those of UNHCR, the United Nations or its Member States.|
Thursday's UN vote adopting key recommendations of the Goldstone report on the conflict in Gaza and southern Israel earlier this year is vitally important for ensuring that those, on both sides, who committed war crimes and other violations of international law will now be held to account, said Amnesty International.
"Both Israel and Hamas in Gaza have been served due notice, in this defining General Assembly resolution, that they must immediately conduct credible, independent investigations into the alleged grave violations of human rights and humanitarian law committed during the conflict," said Yvonne Terlingen, Head of Amnesty International's Office at the UN on Thursday.
"The clock is now running and we urge both parties to act without further delay. The UN has spoken up today for accountability and for an end to the cycle of impunity that has for so long obstructed the search for peace and justice between Israelis and Palestinians."
The UN General Assembly resolution, based on the findings of the UN Fact Finding Mission led by Justice Goldstone, which concluded that both Israeli and Palestinian forces committed war crimes and possibly crimes against humanity, was adopted by a large majority: 114 states voted in favour, 18 voted against and 44 abstained. The USA and 7 European Union (EU) states voted against the resolution while Russia abstained.
"We deeply regret that the USA and the Czech Republic, Germany, Hungary, Italy, the Netherlands, Poland and Slovakia voted against the resolution and failed to support the need for accountability, justice and human rights that are so vital for victims of abuses in this conflict," said Terlingen.
The resolution calls on the UN Secretary-General to transmit Judge Goldstone's report to the Security Council, which has powers to refer the situation in Gaza to the Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court if Israel and Hamas prove unable or unwilling to conduct independent investigations that meet international standards. It also calls on the UN Secretary-General to present a progress report to the General Assembly in three months' time.
"We urge the UN Secretary-General to now appoint independent experts in human rights and international humanitarian law to assess whether any investigations that are conducted by Israel and Hamas meet the required international standard", said Terlingen.
The findings of the Goldstone report echo those of an Amnesty International team that investigated alleged violations in Gaza and southern Israel during and in the immediate aftermath of the conflict, in which hundreds of Palestinian civilians, including some 300 children, and three Israeli civilians were killed.
"Almost one year on, those who suffered war crimes and other gross violations of their rights, are still waiting for justice", said Amnesty International. "It is our fervent hope that today's UN General Assembly resolution will act as a catalyst to make justice and reparation a reality for the victims on both sides."
Amnesty International has asked the Israeli authorities for the third time if they are investigating any of the alleged human rights violations committed by the IDF during the conflict and brought to their attention by the organization.
In a letter to Israel's Judge Advocate General, Brigadier General Avihai Mandelblit, on Friday, Amnesty International said:
"We note that the Israeli NGO B'Tselem made public a report on 4 November 2009 which details 13 cases raised by B'Tselem and other human rights NGOs that are said to be under investigation by the Military Police Investigation Unit. The list does not include Amnesty International as a source of cases of alleged violations brought to the attention of the Israeli authorities."
Amnesty International is waiting for a response from the Israeli authorities with regard to 36 cases – some of which were mentioned in B'Tselem's report – that the organization raised with them on 25 March and 28 September 2009.
Read MoreUN General Assembly must end war crimes whitewash (News, 3 November 2009)
Irene Khan urges US government to examine Goldstone report (News, 18 September 2009)
UN must ensure Goldstone inquiry recommendations are implemented (News, 15 September 2009
Lives lost, lives destroyed in Gaza (News, 22 January 2009)
Amnesty International team talks to Gaza survivors (News, 21 January 2009)
Amnesty International team reports from the rubble of Gaza (News, 20 January 2009)
Israel used white phosphorus in Gaza civilian areas (News, 19 January 2009)
Amnesty International team gains access to Gaza (News, 19 January 2009)
Shelling of UN compound must be investigated (News, 15 January 2009)
Arms embargo vital as Gaza civilian toll mounts (News, 15 January 2009)
Growing calls for investigations and accountability in Gaza conflict (News, 14 January 2009)
Conflict in Gaza and Southern Israel (Amnesty International page)