Last Updated: Tuesday, 02 September 2014, 12:27 GMT

UAE: Stop Expulsion of Bidun Activist

Publisher Human Rights Watch
Publication Date 15 July 2012
Cite as Human Rights Watch, UAE: Stop Expulsion of Bidun Activist, 15 July 2012, available at: http://www.refworld.org/docid/500558012.html [accessed 2 September 2014]
DisclaimerThis is not a UNHCR publication. UNHCR is not responsible for, nor does it necessarily endorse, its content. Any views expressed are solely those of the author or publisher and do not necessarily reflect those of UNHCR, the United Nations or its Member States.

United Arab Emirates (UAE) authorities should halt plans to expel an activist and blogger to Thailand on July 16, 2012, and immediately free him. Authorities have detained Ahmed Abd al-Khaleq, an advocate for the rights of stateless residents known as Bidun, without charge or explanation since May 22.

Abd al-Khaleq, 35, is himself a Bidun, which translates as "without," but was born and has lived all his life in the UAE. In June, prison authorities told him to choose between indefinite detention at the al-Sadr prison in Abu Dhabi or exile to one of a list of countries. He agreed go to Thailand, though he has no connection to Thailand and has never traveled outside the UAE. It appears unlikely that UAE authorities will allow him to return, Human Rights Watch said.

"UAE authorities are trying to make it appear as though Ahmed Abd al-Khaleq is choosing to leave the country on his own volition, but this is a cruel and unlawful expulsion by duress, plain and simple," said Sarah Leah Whitson, Middle East director at Human Rights Watch. "The UAE authorities are ever creative in coming up with outrageous tactics to silence dissenting voices."

Authorities detained Abd al-Khaleq after summoning him to the immigration department of the Interior Ministry in the Ajman emirate, local activists told Human Rights Watch. Local activists told Human Rights Watch that he had applied for Comoros citizenship under pressure from UAE authorities, who told him that obtaining a nationality was a necessary step in regularizing his residency status in the UAE, and had been notified the day before that it had been approved. He has no connection to the Comoros and has never visited the islands. If expelled, Abd al-Khaleq would leave behind his parents and seven sisters, all of whom were born in the UAE and have never left the country.

A local activist whom Abd al-Khaleq has contacted twice from prison told Human Rights Watch that authorities initially informed him that he would be deported to the Comoros immediately, but then took no action for several weeks. In June, authorities presented Abd al-Khaleq with a list of several countries to which he could go, including Iran, Pakistan, Bangladesh, India, and Thailand. Fearing indefinite detention, Abd al-Khaleq reluctantly selected Thailand, though he has no prospect of earning a legal income there and does not know if he will be allowed to stay once his visa expires, the activist said.

On July 3, the prison called Abd al-Khaleq's father and asked him to buy a plane ticket and to apply for a Thai visa for his son. Abd al-Khaleq's father went to al-Sadr prison and collected Abd al-Khaleq's Comoros passport to apply for the visa, which Thai authorities issued on July 5.

Photos circulated by family members of Abd al-Khaleq's Comoros passport, which Human Rights Watch has viewed, show a single-entry tourist visa for Thailand that expires on October 4. The visa explicitly prohibits Abd al-Khaleq from working while he is in the country.

Abd al-Khaleq's blog, Emaraty Bedoon, hosts videos and statements highlighting the plight of stateless residents. According to Refugees International, between 10,000 and 100,000 Bidun live in the UAE. Because of their stateless status, they face severe obstacles in many areas such as access to healthcare and education, and many live in poverty. Many trace their origins to nomadic tribes that previously moved freely around the gulf region or later immigrants living in the UAE who failed to register for nationality when the country was formed in 1971.

UAE activists told Human Rights Watch that Interior Ministry officials have stepped up pressure on stateless residents in recent months to apply for Comoros citizenship, telling them that their window to apply would soon close, which would jeopardize their chances of establishing legal residency in the UAE.

Abd al-Khaleq is one of a group of activists who had been jailed from April to November 2011 for peacefully advocating democratic reforms. The activists, known as the UAE 5, were detained in April 2011, after they allegedly posted statements on UAE Hewar, an internet forum that criticized UAE government policy and leaders.

UAE authorities charged them in early June 2011 under articles 176 and 8 of the UAE Penal Code, which criminalize "public insults" of the country's top officials. They were detained throughout a seven-month pretrial and trial process. The Federal Supreme Court convicted them on November 27 and sentenced them to between two and three years in prison. Shortly afterward, Shaikh Khalifa bin Zayed Al Nahyan, the UAE president, commuted the sentences and they were released. Abd al-Khaleq is the only stateless member of the UAE 5.

Abd al-Khaleq's latest detention follows a series of arrests of dissidents in the UAE. Since March, authorities have detained without charge 12 members of the Reform and Social Guidance Association (al-Islah), a non-violent political association advocating greater adherence to Islamic precepts. One of the lawyers for the detained men told Human Rights Watch that the authorities said they arrested six of the men for refusing to sign a pledge to seek another nationality after the government claimed to have revoked their citizenship.

The United Nations Declaration on Human Rights Defenders provides that countries should "take all necessary measures to ensure the protection of everyone against any violence, threats, retaliation, adverse discrimination, pressure or any other arbitrary action" as a result of their participation in human rights activity.

International law protects the right to family life. Article 33 of the Arab Charter for Human Rights provides that, "The State and society shall ensure the protection of the family, the strengthening of family ties, [and] the protection of its members…" The UN Human Rights Committee has set out in General Comment 19 that, in addition to the obligation on states to protect the family, "the right to found a family implies ... the possibility to ... live together.... Similarly, the possibility to live together implies the adoption of appropriate measures ... to ensure the unity or reunification of families, particularly when their members are separated for political, economic or similar reasons." Deporting a person under conditions in which they would have to leave their family and go to a place where it would not be reasonable for the family to move would violate the right to family life, Human Rights Watch said.

"This expulsion would not only ship Abd al-Khaleq to a distant land where he has no realistic hope of making a home, but it would also sentence his family to a bleak and uncertain future," Whitson said.

Copyright notice: © Copyright, Human Rights Watch

Search Refworld